Free domestic shipping on orders over ¥10,000
search

How Might an Exhibition Be Remembered?
— A Conversation Marking the Publication of 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21


Cover of 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21.2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

On the To-Come was held in Aomori City from 16 May to 22 June 2026. For this group exhibition, twelve artists from a range of disciplines presented work in a vacant commercial building that had formerly housed a karaoke venue, responding to the question, ‘What if photography disappeared from the world?’

Four months after the exhibition closed, IACK published 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, an artist’s book that grew out of the exhibition. What does it mean to open an exhibition up to people? What is the significance of an archive? And what is left behind: memory, or omoide (recollections)? We present a conversation held at early spring gallery & shop in Tokyo on 31 October, between Naohiro Utagawa and Suguru Ryuzaki, who initiated the exhibition, and its co-organiser, Yukihito Kono.

Opening the Question Beyond Photographers

Yukihito Kono: To start with, could the two of you tell us what sort of group exhibition On the To-Come was, and how the idea for it came about?

Naohiro Utagawa: I was thinking about things like what would happen if photography disappeared, and I posted on Twitter that I’d like to put on an exhibition around that theme. Then Suguru responded—he’d been having similar thoughts, or something along those lines. And that led to us saying, let’s do an exhibition.

For me, the concern behind all this, the reason I’d been thinking about what would happen if photography disappeared, was that I had this feeling that it’s a little strange for photography to be so heavily dependent on industry in the first place, and yet for us to be able to present it to the world as art. If photography disappeared—or rather, if the manufacturers stopped making their products—then photography would disappear, wouldn’t it? I keep vaguely wondering what those of us who call ourselves photographers would call ourselves then. So I’d been thinking about what kinds of photography might be possible. I posted about that, and Suguru responded. That’s how it happened.

Suguru Ryuzaki: I may just be going over exactly what Naohiro has said, but photography—well, perhaps that isn’t strictly true—but it really does depend enormously on cameras and film and things like that. So I feel like all of us photographers are living with that sort of vulnerability, or something like it.

The timing of Naohiro’s post on Twitter coincided with things like colour photographic paper disappearing, or production being discontinued. I imagine it’s different for people working digitally, but it was exactly the situation I was facing myself, so I thought, everyone really is thinking about this. It started with something as small as that, but the more I thought about it, the more I wondered whether perhaps we ought to put forward one possible response now. And Naohiro was quite enthusiastic in his replies to me, too. So I thought, perhaps we should give this a go. That was how it began.

Exterior of the building that housed the exhibition.The building that housed On the To-Come | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

YK: The three of us organising it are all artists who work with photography, and I think you could call this a photography-specific, specialist concern. It ended up being a group exhibition with twelve artists, but not many of the other participants would describe themselves as photographers, would they? How did that come about?

NU: Yes, exactly. With ‘What if photography disappeared?’, I felt that if only photographers took on this question, we’d end up referring to quite a narrow idea of photography. When photographers try to respond to ‘What if photography disappeared?’, it’s photography as photographers understand it, or photography as an artwork, you could say. That’s quite a closed way of looking at photography. So I thought it might be better to ask other people who use photography to respond as well. In our original plans, we were also considering people from an even wider range of professions, including people who don’t make art.

SR: Just to add to that, photography isn’t only something you make into art. There’s advertising, photographs taken to mark an occasion, and so on. I think the way people engage with it varies completely from one person to another. So, as you say, having photographers decide everything would be incredibly closed. I didn’t like how inward-looking that felt.

YK: It started from the concerns of people who specialise in photography, but as you’ve both just said, there’s no one now who doesn’t see or use photographs in everyday life, is there? That’s why I thought it might be interesting that people would interpret this question, ‘What if photography disappeared?’, in different ways.

And when we went on to invite the artists, we sent them a proposal, of course, but deliberately didn’t set out a strict definition of ‘photography’, did we? Some people, like Naohiro and Suguru, thought about what we would do if photography disappeared as an industry—things to do with machinery, or systems. Others thought that if photography disappeared, its role in society would disappear too, and perhaps something would change in the images photography produces, or things of that kind. That was what I personally found interesting.

Artists Creating Their Own Spaces and Opportunities

YK: And when we actually talk about the exhibition, we can’t ignore what was distinctive about the venue. Could you tell us a little about how you came to choose the space in Aomori, and about the place itself?

SR: There’s a woman from a later year at my university who works in architecture in her hometown of Aomori, and she’s working there with her family now. The firm she works for has quite a few vacant commercial spaces like this. Aomori gets a lot of snow, so places like these do deteriorate if they’re left unattended. She’s an artist as well, so she’s been working on using these places, which already have some of the basic infrastructure in place, as art spaces or something along those lines. The place we used for this exhibition is one of them.

It used to be a karaoke place called U-Style, and there are still traces of that in the space. It’s a huge space, spread across three entire floors. Even with the number of us taking part, it was on a scale that would be difficult to achieve in Tokyo. So I thought it might be worth talking to her about it. That was how it came about.

YK: This was an exhibition initiated by artists, and we also did all the work of making it happen ourselves. Was there a reason you wanted to do it with just artists, without bringing in curators or people who specialise in running exhibitions, or relying on grants?

NU: I was thinking about all sorts of things at the time, but I’m not sure I can properly remember them off the top of my head now [Laughs]. This moves away from photography a bit, but when I thought about what it means to live, to keep going, I felt it was important for artists themselves to create their own spaces and opportunities. I didn’t think it was very good to be in a situation where you had no work unless someone invited you. So, for me, that was why I thought, let’s try doing it with just artists.

YK: The venue wasn’t originally designed for exhibitions, so there were restrictions on lighting and installing work, and there were traces of how it had been fitted out as a karaoke place, all the various facilities that had been put in. When you’re deciding whose work goes where, I think the ideal in a conventional exhibition is to plan it with the relationships between the works in mind. But in this case, because of the restrictions, it was more like, this work has to go here, so this person’s work will go there. In a sense, the layout of the exhibition took shape from the opposite direction.

But one advantage of putting on an exhibition like this in Aomori, as Suguru was saying, is that you can do things on a scale you couldn’t in Tokyo and places like that. When making work, you don’t have to think too much about the dimensions of the space, you could say. I thought that was really good.

Installation view of There is nothing outside the window. Or everything. It is the same. by Yukihito Kono.

Yukihito Kono, There is nothing outside the window. Or everything. It is the same. | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of La carte postale by Suguru Ryuzaki.

Suguru Ryuzaki, La carte postale | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of Keep Pointing Until the End by Ai Tanaka.

Ai Tanaka, Keep Pointing Until the End | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of Schrödinger’s Cat—On Memory by Sachie Noda.

Sachie Noda, Schrödinger’s Cat—On Memory | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of Mare Baltide / Sundari Sundara / Chandra by Yuko Amano.

Yuko Amano, Mare Baltide / Sundari Sundara / Chandra | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of 15:30 / 8:35 by Shoko Masunaga.

Shoko Masunaga, 15:30 / 8:35 | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of After the Pencil of Nature / Crown Ether (18-crown-6-Li⁺ in CH₃CN) by Aya Coizumi.

Aya Coizumi, After the Pencil of Nature / Crown Ether (18-crown-6-Li⁺ in CH₃CN) | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of stars can’t stop talking / Untitled by Ryuji Takahara.

Ryuji Takahara, stars can’t stop talking / Untitled | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of Positive Void (Orange and Lemon) by Yuri Tsuiki.

Yuri Tsuiki, Positive Void (Orange and Lemon) | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of I Guess Everything Reminds You of Something by Naohiro Utagawa.

Naohiro Utagawa, I Guess Everything Reminds You of Something | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of COPY DOWN by Kota Aigase.

Kota Aigase, COPY DOWN | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

Installation view of Untitled by Koji Yamaguchi.

Koji Yamaguchi, Untitled | Photo ©︎ Naohiro Utagawa

1 / 12

Making a Book to Open the Exhibition Up Again

YK: On the other hand, though, because of the location, there’s the reality that only a limited number of people can visit, even if the exhibition runs for a month. So, around the time the exhibition opened—or perhaps a little before that, I can’t remember—the three of us talked about how we really needed to think seriously about opening this exhibition up to people who couldn’t come in person. But I personally found it quite difficult to work out how to do that in practice. If we took a conventional approach to putting it together, we could have a round-table discussion with the participating artists, for instance, or publish a text made up of interviews, combined with installation photographs to make a catalogue of sorts. Those ideas did actually come up. And there’s nothing wrong with that, but... how can I put it? Alongside the exhibition’s theme of ‘What would you do if photography disappeared?’, there was also what was so interesting about the space itself. I personally had doubts about whether putting it all into an existing format and leaving it behind like that would really open the exhibition up, or create an archive of it. So time went by without us finding an answer.

We did have something set up where the artists entered information about their work and their processes into a spreadsheet, so anyone accessing it could see information about the works and how they were made. It should still be available now. You can access the information there, but still, I found myself facing the difficulty of archiving all over again.

As well as being an artist, I work with books, so that makes me think all the more about how to preserve something by turning it into another form, or how to archive it. And photography itself is like that too, isn’t it? Photography has this quality of making a record, so there’s always a connection with archiving. But at the same time, given the exhibition’s theme, using photographic documentation to make a book somehow felt like putting the cart before the horse.

Sorry to keep going on, but about two days before the exhibition ended, an image suddenly came into my head. Why not decide that we could supplement the archive, to a certain extent, with video and material online? In fact, online you can do more than you can in a book—you can add links to all sorts of other pages and jump straight to them, and do things in all kinds of ways. Books can function as archives too, of course, but now even libraries have more books than they can hold, and books are being thrown away. Those are problems that are actually happening. Thinking about that made me question this idea of online versus physical formats, where the physical format’s capacity for preservation is treated as something sacred. At the same time, I began to think that perhaps we don’t need to place quite so much responsibility for archiving on books in the first place.

A lot of the photobooks and art books we stock at IACK are image-led books, so I thought, why not make something like that, something that really focuses on visual information? If someone who’s never been to the exhibition picks it up, they won’t know anything about the exhibition, but we could start with them finding it interesting visually, or as a physical object. And if that then led them to take an interest in the exhibition... I thought that might create another route, a more open one, with room for chance encounters and things like that, rather than making what you’d call an archive book. So that’s why I made this book.

Naohiro, today was your first chance to see the actual book. What were your thoughts on archiving, on preserving an exhibition?

NU: At first, you know, I did have this feeling that we should make a proper archive. And my idea of an archive is that the more there is, the better. That’s just what I like. I’d vaguely assumed, on my own, that it would be good to keep all that material. But then I talked with Yukihito, and I think we had a conversation about whether having more and more material preserved in an archive really is a good thing.

For instance, there’s Kota Takeuchi, who made a work about balloon bombs. He uses things like archives of stone monuments as material for his work. He was saying that even stone monuments, which look as if they could last for thousands of years, quickly stop functioning as an archive if there’s no one to look after them. If that’s the case, then however robust an archive you build, it doesn’t offer much resistance to that after all—or I find myself feeling that perhaps it won’t.

Of course, we might not fully achieve that original aim of ‘How do we preserve an exhibition for other people when it’s such a limited opportunity, in a particular place?’ But I feel that what stays with you in the end is more that you’ve glimpsed something. That’s how I feel at the moment.

Glimpsing the Exhibition Through a Book

NU: So, somehow, when I flicked through this book, I did have that feeling of ‘catching a glimpse’. You catch a quick glimpse through a crack somewhere and walk on, or you turn back and think, ‘Hang on, what was that?’ It felt like a book for looking back, and then going somewhere from there, and I thought that was good.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

YK: That’s good to hear. I’m pleased. Because that idea of ‘catching a glimpse’ was very much on my mind. I thought I might be able to make a book, so I went from Kanazawa to Aomori on the last day of the exhibition. If you’re going there and back in a day, you only have about two or three hours at the venue. I thought it would be better to have plenty of material to work with, so I’d leave a record in a few different ways, and shooting video was one of them.

But that video wasn’t for what you’d normally call archival purposes either. I’d already decided to make something that moved away from accuracy and faithful reproduction, so it was a little different from leaving a record as documentation. As a photographer, I filmed it in a way that drew a little more on a kind of photographic physicality, or the ability to respond in an instant.

For an accurate record, we already had the installation shots Naohiro had taken, and there was a really substantial amount of visual material. But still, how can I put it? It was about catching a glimpse, and there was something about the specificity of the place too. Some things only made sense if you’d actually been there, and even if you tried to reproduce them, there would be limits to what you could do.

I did shoot a lot of video, but unlike working with photographs, I’m still not at all used to editing video. And sitting in front of a screen watching all that footage back takes so much time, and I was even finding it painful, so I just wasn’t getting round to watching it. As the deadline approached, I kept working on ideas without properly looking at it, until I finally got myself moving and thought, right, let’s watch it through once, at least. Then I opened the files in order and played them, taking screenshots of anything that caught my attention, one after another, really as though I was looking back through my memory. I made this book from the screenshots that came out of that single viewing. So I also felt as though I’d caught another glimpse of the exhibition.

That process is reflected in the book as it is, so after hearing what we’ve said so far, or the exhibition’s concept, you might approach it quite seriously and start thinking about things like ‘What is photography?’ But ideally, I’d like people to look at it visually, quite casually, without thinking too hard, in the same way they would a photobook or an image-led book. Suguru, you’re joining us online today and haven’t seen a physical copy of the book yet, but what did you think?

SR: I was looking at Instagram, thinking, ‘Today’s the last day of the exhibition,’ and I saw that Yukihito was on a bullet train to Tokyo. I thought, ‘Oh, he’s away for work again this week,’ and then he was already heading for Aomori. I wondered, ‘What’s he going there for?’ and then he was going to shoot video. That really surprised me. I thought, he really has just decided to do this on the spur of the moment.

With Yukihito shooting that video to make this book, I felt it was complete. When he told me about this idea, it really struck a chord with me.

Of course, an archive, at its simplest, is something you leave in words and photographs, I think. But the reason Naohiro originally said he wanted to leave things in a spreadsheet, or make one, was that not many people could actually come to Aomori. Even for someone who hasn’t seen the works themselves, the artists’—how do I put it?—the pieces of prose and everyday life that accumulate on the way to making the work might, for the first time, make it possible to describe that exhibition. I think that was the idea you put forward.

And this isn’t an archive, exactly, but I really felt that, by making this image-led book out of screenshots from video, it might convey the atmosphere that could only arise in that place, and the cruelty of memory, things like that, with more of their original force than properly taken documentary photographs and text could. Artists are always thinking about how to express what can’t be put into words, aren’t they? And I felt that this might have been a final answer to that. Sorry. That sounded like something out of a script.

Cover of 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 6–7.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 28–29.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 60–61.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 66–67.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 84–85.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, pages 124–125.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

Spread from 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21, page 160 and the inside back cover.

2026.6.22 13:30–15:21 | ©︎ IACK

1 / 8

Between Memory and Omoide

A note on terms: The conversation distinguishes two overlapping Japanese words: kioku, rendered here as ‘memory’, and omoide, which is close to ‘recollections’ but has no exact English equivalent, so it is left in Japanese.

NU: There’s a manga called Yotsuba&!. Our house is a mess, it’s cluttered, and there’s always a copy lying around. On the paper band wrapped round the book, I think it says, ‘Memory or omoide?’ Every time I see that band, I find myself going, hmm.

‘Memory or omoide?’ presents you with two choices, so I find myself wondering which it is. In texts about the concepts behind photographs, people generally use ‘memory’, don’t they? You don’t really see omoide. I keep thinking about why that is, and what gets stripped away by not using that word, omoide.

Personally, I feel that omoide might be the richer word. Omoide has, hmm, more humidity to it, you could say. There’s smell, humidity, taste, irritation, happiness, things like that. Memory—well, I suppose memory has those things too, but perhaps what’s shared is a little different.

I don’t know where I’m going to land with this yet. I still don’t know. What we entrust to photographs—in everyday life, I feel we’re mostly photographing things that are more like omoide, but when they become artworks, we probably start talking about ‘memory’, or something like that. You know, it’s… But what is it, really?

I find myself thinking about those things. I haven’t found an answer yet, but memory and omoide in the context of ‘What if photography disappeared?’—how do I put it? And then there’s ‘record’ as a separate word too. I find myself wondering which nuances I mean when I use them.

YK: I see. Hearing that, I can sort of understand that desire of yours to cover absolutely everything, Naohiro. I do feel there’s something there. That moving back and forth between them. What we usually call an archive feels like collecting data from an objective position, an objective point of view. But the questions you put to each artist this time, I seem to remember, were more about omoide connected with the work or the process, things like that, rather than questions designed to collect data from a neutral position.

But yes, that might be something I was thinking about when making this book too. Those of us artists who could go went there to install the work, somehow got it all into shape, and then there was a party, ‘Ah, thank goodness,’ and it was over, ‘Well done, everyone,’ that sort of thing. Partly because we’d done everything ourselves, I went home full of this euphoria, thinking how good it had all been. That’s pure omoide.

But that’s probably something only the people who went there—or rather, the people who organised it—could have. An exhibition needs people to come and see it, though, and I don’t know whether those feelings alone make it work as an exhibition. I needed to look at it objectively again and ask whether this exhibition had been good. To be honest, I hadn’t thought about that at all at the opening, or hadn’t had the space to, but as we got closer and closer to the end, those feelings gradually began to surface for me.

Of course, we could just leave it entirely as omoide. When you report afterwards that ‘We had this exhibition’, you can tell that story any way you like. If you leave it in photographs, or make a book of it, you can idealise it as much as you want and make a beautiful record as an object. I’m an artist, but I’m also in a position where I select and sell books and show other artists’ work, so being very careful about that is something I think about all the time.

So I went back there on the last day. There was one member of staff helping out, and none of the other participants were there. By looking at the exhibition again, calmly, in that building surrounded by the sound of heavy rain, I think I shifted, for a while, from omoide to memory.

But then, when it takes another form through watching the video back, taking screenshots and making a book, paradoxically, when information is stripped away, things outside that information start to stand out more, you could say. It’s difficult to explain, but it seems to return to something quite close to omoide. Some of the screenshots are a little blurred, and precisely because they’re quite abstract and leave space, there might be room, or a possibility, for them to connect with someone’s memory, even if that person has never been to the place and might have no connection with any of it.

Or when someone picks up this book in a bookshop while travelling, or in their neighbourhood, there might be space for it to connect with their omoide of a conversation they had then, or of the trip itself. I did feel that memory and omoide were an important theme in this exhibition.

Screenshot taken from the exhibition footage.
Screenshot taken from the exhibition footage.

Screenshots taken from the footage | ©︎ Yukihito Kono

1 / 2

NU: If you asked whether that’s all photography does, I’d say it isn’t. Yukihito, for example, you responded by making a hole in a ping-pong ball, saying that optical mechanisms and natural phenomena would remain. In my case, I give photographs to my child’s nursery, for my child’s album. The album has pictures of things my child likes, and happy omoide. It’s saying, ‘You think you like this, don’t you?’ or ‘You think this is fun, don’t you?’ It’s a kind of socialisation, you could say, that function or use of photography as a mirror. I was thinking a little about how you’d bring up a child if that disappeared, or what else could be given that function.

Coming back to the book, personally, those screenshots taken one after another look more like omoide to me, or I feel they’ve taken on a kind of humidity that’s very much like omoide. And that isn’t documentation, really. With documentation, as Yukihito was saying earlier, when you’re asked to be honest, there are parts where you have to tell a little lie, or be a little categorical, aren’t there? You present it as ‘This is what it was. It was good.’ You can’t present it as a failure. And when faced with that, the decision to say, ‘Right, let’s take an honest approach,’ has led to this. It’s very much like omoide, or that’s how it feels to me, anyway.

Being Both Artist and Organiser

YK: I’ve made quite a few artist’s books, zines and photobooks of my own, but this was my first experience of making something out of an exhibition that involved other people’s work. There were some things I found quite difficult.

Because I was the publisher, and I was using material I’d produced myself, I wanted to maintain a degree of objectivity. That’s part of why I published it through IACK rather than as a self-published book. How can I put it? I was the one doing the filming, but I wanted to leave something that could exist as an objective image.

Perhaps it was precisely because that was so difficult that I tried to find a balance by leaving information out, introducing a kind of anonymity where you don’t know who took the images or what exhibition they show. Did you have any similar concerns when organising the exhibition? You’re taking part as an artist, but your name is there as an organiser too.

NU: Yes, exactly. I had a strong feeling that maybe you shouldn’t include yourself in something you’re curating. But the reason I decided to stop thinking that way was that, after all, I’m an artist as someone living a life. First someone living a life, and also an artist. If that’s where you start, then what’s wrong with us taking action ourselves? I thought, well, maybe it’s fine. This is how we do things from the artist’s side.

YK: That’s true. There isn’t much else you can do. In a way, that’s also why I run IACK. When you think about making a life as a photographer, as an artist, there might be a certain established image of what that looks like, a path you’re supposed to follow. But in reality, only a handful of people can work that way.

When you stray from that path, when you start working in another direction, it may connect with your everyday life, or it may not. It’s different for everyone, but as someone living a life, you have to think of something. That’s why, this time, although bringing in specialists might have made some things easier, it mattered that we showed a position through the way we worked. I think the three of us each came to it with that kind of background.

SR: Yes. Early on, Naohiro and I did talk about bringing in a curator or a gallerist. But it was also an exhibition theme that perhaps only artists could have come up with, so we ended up saying that it might feel a bit strange to have someone else step in and steer it.

NU: To come back to photography, in the first place we’re borrowing something that already exists, aren’t we? We’re taking something we didn’t make ourselves, something produced by forces much larger than us, using it as we please and calling it our work.

I brought that way of thinking about photography to my role in running the exhibition too. In that sense, I wanted to avoid bringing in, as far as possible, any power relations that might rule something out.

The question ‘What if photography disappeared?’ also asks what would happen if those enormous forces disappeared. And part of my own theme was how to make photographs from within the home. So there was a sense that the exhibition itself, too, needed to be made by people living their own lives. That’s part of why I wanted us to do it just as artists.

The floor and tools at the venue during adjustments after closing on the first day.

Adjustments after closing on the first day | ©︎ Yukihito Kono

A message reading, “A bear has been spotted near the venue.”

Trouble during installation | ©︎ Yukihito Kono

1 / 2

Returning to the Question

YK: I see. So, for now, it has taken this form as a book. Do you see any ways it might develop from here? Or does it become omoide?

NU: Shall we just leave it as omoide? [Laughs]

I do want to do something, though. For instance, tonoko powder has apparently gone out of production, or something. I’ve only ever used it on the surface of wood as a finish. Apparently it’s used in lacquerwork. I don’t know what it’s used for there at all, though.

There are any number of things like that. I also do a bit of ceramics, and apparently there used to be people who made a living just collecting and selling ash from plants and trees. There must have been all these small, specialised industries. When those industries disappear, something you’ve been confidently calling ‘art’ can suddenly become impossible to do.

But art, in the Western conception of art, is somehow presented as something permanent, something institutionally secure, isn’t it? Yet without the work of the people supporting those small industries, it couldn’t exist at all. I really feel that contrast. So, in that sense, ‘What if photography disappeared?’ is very much a question I’d like to keep returning to.

YK: Yes. To give a personal example, I was recently invited to a photobook festival in Norway as both an artist and a curator. While I was writing my curatorial statement, I realised that we’re always saying things like ‘We’re living in a time of upheaval.’

During the pandemic, for instance, or when AI technology emerged, or around the start of the Trump administration, and before that too, I’ve been writing or reading the same kind of thing. When I read older writing on photography, I get the sense that people in every era have probably been saying it.

Of course, the speed at which AI is developing is astonishing, and climate change is serious. But ‘This is a time of change’ is something we seem to be saying all the time. With photography too, from the arrival of digital technology to the shift towards it, it feels like this question comes up regularly.

So it’s fine to ask what critical relevance the question has each time, but it might also be interesting to revisit it at certain points and compare it with past exhibitions that posed the same question.

NU: Yes, that’s true. I get the feeling people must have done it before. There might have been an exhibition asking, ‘What if LaserDiscs disappeared?’ And there was the Y2K problem, wasn’t there?

YK: There was. [Laughs]

NU: And then nothing happened. After all that fuss. I think it probably was a time of upheaval. ‘The world is going to end.’

YK: Maybe it has ended a few times, actually. [Laughs] Or come close to ending, several times. Wars, and things that put us in real physical danger, are still happening in society now. Being aware that we’re always living in the midst of that lets us take stock again of, well, where we are. I think that’s one reason the question matters.

But I think ‘What if photography disappeared?’ is a question worth considering at this particular moment, even if you’re not a photographer. Personally, it’s less about putting it forward as a critical topic than about the fact that we’re thinking about these things now, in this time and under these circumstances. That in itself seems meaningful to me.

NU: Right. As a topic, it might seem natural to look back and ask, ‘What was photography?’ But in the end, none of us really went that far into it. What did we mean by photography here? What answers were there that could take its place? We could dig into those questions if we wanted to.

YK: What I found interesting was that these discussions usually end up centring on technology. People make work by asking what they’d do if the components or the machines disappeared. I think you can find examples of that in past contemporary art exhibitions. But in this exhibition, there was hardly any work that dealt directly with technology in that way.

NU: There wasn’t, apart from Kota Aigase’s work using AI.

YK: You might expect there to have been more, but I think it was a good balance that people didn’t all head in that direction. The fact that we came from different backgrounds, that we weren’t all photographers, was already doing something there. Showing, through things rather than words, what the disappearance of photography might mean to people working in different fields.

I do find something interesting in showing things through things. Of course, artists sometimes go out of their way to use words, as we’re doing here. But there’s something interesting about choosing to offer or communicate something through the more roundabout means of an artwork. What seems most meaningful to me is that photographers’ sense of unease about the industry, and a casual tweet, led to this exhibition, this book, and this conversation.

The venue after the book launch conversation.©︎ early spring gallery & shop

This article was edited from the book launch conversation held at early spring gallery & shop on 31 October 2026.

Edited by Yukihito Kono
Supported by early spring gallery & shop

Cover of 2026.6.22 13:30–15:21.

Book Information
2026.6.22 13:30–15:21
Edited by Yukihito Kono and Yuta Murao
Designed by Yuta Murao
Published by IACK, October 2026
Softcover, PUR perfect binding, 160 pages
Dimensions: 182 × 118 × 17 mm
Language: English
First edition of 300 copies
Price: ¥3,850

▶ Order online
www.iack.online/en/products/2026-6-22-13-30-15-21

Stockists
IACK (Kanazawa)
early spring gallery & shop (Tokyo)
MULU (Taipei, Taiwan)
Rope Editions (Seoul, South Korea)

Related Video
Imagining a World Without Photography | On the To-Come Exhibition Tour

Subscribe to our newsletter for early updates on new articles and events. You can sign up using the form at the bottom of the page.